(Not contraceptives by the way. And they still can pay for your abortions, it's called your paycheck.)
Needless to say, this has some of the stupidest arguments I've ever seen. At some point it gets back to how fetus and embryos are not alive or something. One in particular caught my eye. It starts with Sean Davis letting them have it:
You're welcome to argue that human life doesn't begin with a fertilized egg so long as you don't also argue that you understand science.
— Sean Davis (@seanmdav) June 30, 2014
Which leads to this piece of driftwood forming a tweet:
@seanmdav @EWErickson It isn't anymore than a fingernail is alive on its own.
— Andy Caldwell (@AndyCaldwell_2) June 30, 2014
I had to get in on this.
@AndyCaldwell_2 @seanmdav @EWErickson Aren't fingernails and human embryos different?
— Conservative Yoda (@YodaCon) July 1, 2014
@YodaCon In terms of being alive on there own, no.Ok, that is the narrowest definition of comparison you could make. Why? So you can get what you want, which is unlimited abortions.
— Andy Caldwell (@AndyCaldwell_2) July 1, 2014
Fingernails = Not Alive on their own
Embryos = Not Alive on their own.
Therefore
Fingernails = Embryos.
This is silliness to the ultimate degree. And I told him so:
@AndyCaldwell_2 Well I guess if we define it by the most narrowest of parameters, then sure. So much for the "nuanced" party. @seanmdav
— Conservative Yoda (@YodaCon) July 1, 2014
But we're dealing with driftwood here.
@YodaCon @seanmdav Ok? So are you agreeing with me?
— Andy Caldwell (@AndyCaldwell_2) July 1, 2014
No. But I'm beginning to think you are the fingernail that we're talking about. Fortunately Sean helps me out and I thank him.
@AndyCaldwell_2 @YodaCon You compared a baby to a fingernail. Nobody is agreeing with you. We are mocking you. Quite openly, as it were.
— Sean Davis (@seanmdav) July 1, 2014
Well it went on from there but you get the idea. Narrow your argument down to something inconsequential and meaningless and then hang yourself with it. Fingernails are not embryos. He wants us to try to put a fingernail clipping at the same worth as the embryo and they are not. Gold and Mercury are both elements and in a way are far less complex and far more alike than an embryo and a fingernail. Hell they are only one proton off. But Gold and Mercury are vastly different in their properties, their worth, and their effect on a human being. We don't elevate a fingernail to that of an embryo but he degrades an embryo to that of a fingernail.
An embryo's effect on a human being is vastly different than a fingernail's. Only a liberal couldn't see that.
No comments:
Post a Comment